|
By ROBERT E. NELSON
The expanding presence and growing influence of South Asian students
and professionals in American society is presenting American higher
education institutions with both challenges and opportunities. Over the
past five years, Harvard University, in Cambridge, Massachusetts, has
taken a leading role in calling for greater engagement between American
universities and the South Asian region. Meanwhile, Indian American
students and visiting students from South Asia have flourished at Harvard,
establishing perhaps the most visible and influential presence on campus
of any cultural or international group. For example, the South Asian
Association's "Ghungroo," an annual, springtime, cultural show nearing its
20th anniversary, is one of the most highly anticipated artistic events at
the university. Yet, Harvard's administration is struggling to keep up
with soaring demand among students for greater resources devoted to South
Asia related activities.
In a speech at the Harvard South Asia Conference in September 2003, the
university's then-president, Lawrence Summers, pronounced a bold call to
action, not only for Harvard but for universities nationwide. "There is an
enormous opportunity to fill a gap," he observed. "There is an enormous
need for us as a nation to enhance our understanding of contemporary South
Asia."
A region on the rise, he said, "commands the attention of a great
university." For Summers, Harvard's role would be to lead the way toward
filling that gap:
"The development and enhancement of our capacity to study South Asia," he
proclaimed, will be "our major inter-national affairs and regional
priority in the years ahead." While calling for improvements, Summers also
paid special tribute to two South Asian scholars already established on
Harvard's campus: Sugata Bose, Gardiner Professor of Oceanic History, and
Amartya Sen, the Nobel Laureate in Economics.
An ambitious proposal
Summers followed up on his speech a few years later with a visit to India
in 2006. Inspired by the experience, upon returning he made the ambitious
proposal that "every American should visit the country that may be our
most important ally two decades from now." Since Summers' resignation from
the presidency last year, leadership of the university has been handed
over to Drew G. Faust, a professor of American history. She will encounter
increasing demand from a vociferous contingent among the undergraduate
student body to revamp and reorganize the school's resources in order to
fulfill Summers' South Asian mission.
Harvard, America's oldest university, has a long history of South Asian
scholarship, though it has been devoted chiefly to philology, the study of
language. Sanskrit was first taught at Harvard in 1872 by James Bradstreet
Greenough, a Latin grammarian. A Sanskrit Reader, published in 1888, by
Charles Lanman, head of the department of Indo-Iranian languages,
continues to serve as Harvard's standard introductory text for the
language. By 1902, interest among students had grown to the extent that a
Department of Indic Philology was formed. Its modern incarnation, the
Department of Sanskrit and Indian Studies, has held strongly to its
linguistic center. Today, a Harvard student can choose from courses
offered in Sanskrit, Vedic, Pali, Urdu-Hindi, Tibetan, Bengali, Nepali,
Sindhi and Gujarati.
Historic roots and modern shortcomings
Today's undergraduates, though, are no longer satisfied with Harvard's
historic tradition of scholarship in South Asian philology. In recent
years the demand for broader regional studies has come especially from
Indian American students and scholars from South Asia, who have formed a
South Asia Studies Initiative. In March of this year, two leaders of the
movement raised the profile of the issue with an opinion piece in the
Harvard Crimson daily newspaper. Vinita Andrapalliyal and Shreya Vora
insisted that South Asian studies must break out of the constraints of
tradition and be elevated above the status of a mere "special interest
issue." Writing at a time of simmering inter-faculty battles over the
undergraduate curriculum, they argued that the study of South Asia has
become "absolutely essential to any curriculum that seeks to make global
citizens of its students."
Academic interest rising
Andrapalliyal and Vora contended that Harvard has not adequately met
growing demand for South Asia related study opportunities. Supporting
their case was the Initiative's 2005 survey that found academic interest
in the region among undergraduates on the rise, and found present
resources inadequate in comparison to peer universities. Lack of resources
and opportunities may be a deterrent to devoting one's studies to the
region, they argued, noting that fewer than 12 percent of students who
were initially interested in concentrating on South Asia studies actually
followed through. Moreover, of 59 students who said they were interested
in going to the region to study, only three eventually signed up.
Students said they are seeking greater breadth and depth in course
offerings, especially in contemporary South Asian politics, culture and
society.
The recently formed South Asia Initiative is a serious attempt by faculty
across disciplines to compensate for the narrow focus of the Sanskrit
department. The Initiative, housed at Harvard's Weatherhead Center for
International Affairs, supports faculty and student exchanges and research
in South Asia, and conducts a broad range of seminars, lectures and
conferences across academic disciplines. In 2005 and 2006, a group from
the Initiative, led by Assistant Director Rena Fonseca, traveled to Tamil
Nadu to assist with tsunami reconstruction projects. Despite these steps
toward Summers' vision, though, the Initiative has yet to become a
heavyweight among Harvard's legions of institutions and faculties. It has
not been granted the power to appoint faculty or grant degrees, and has
limited resources.
Looking ahead, Harvard has much work to do to satisfy the demands of the
students and turn the opportunities envisioned by her predecessor into
realities on campus. In order for South Asian studies to enjoy enhanced
comparative prestige among other regional studies programs and
institutes at Harvard, the South Asia Initiative will need to attract
greater funding and build its capabilities. Faust could persuade the
Sanskrit department to modernize its curriculum to match undergraduate
interests, and could lead a university-wide effort to recruit leading
professors to Harvard departments lacking in South Asian specialists.
Given Harvard's stature and influence in the United States, if the
university can succeed in meeting those challenges, South Asian students
and enthusiasts can expect to find the coming years among the most
exciting in the history of American higher education.
Robert Nelson, a 2007 graduate of Harvard University, wrote this article
while working as a Public Affairs intern at the American Center, New
Delhi.
Please share your views on this article. Write to editorspan@state.gov
South Asian Programs at U.S. Universities
* The Committee on South Asian Studies, Harvard University, Massachusetts
http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~sanskrit/sastudies.html
* Department of Sanskrit and Indian Studies, Harvard University,
Massachusetts
http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~sanskrit/index.html
* South Asia Program, Cornell University, New York
http://www.einaudi.cornell.edu/SouthAsia/
* Southern Asian Institute, Columbia University, New York
http://www.sipa.columbia.edu/REGIONAL/SAI/
* India Studies Program, Indiana University, Bloomington
http://www.indiana.edu/~isp/
* Asian Studies Center, Michigan State University, East Lansing
http://asianstudies.msu.edu/
* South Asia Center, Syracuse University, New York
http://www.maxwell.syr.edu/moynihan/programs/sac/
* Center for South Asia Studies, University of California, Berkeley
http://www.ias.berkeley.edu/southasia/
* South Asia at Chicago, University of Chicago
http://southasia.uchicago.edu/
* Center for Southeast Asian Studies, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
http://www.umich-cseas.org/
* Department of South Asia Studies, University of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia
http://www.southasia.upenn.edu/
* Center for the Advanced Study of India, University of Pennsylvania
http://casi.ssc.upenn.edu/
* Asian Studies, University of Texas at Austin
http://asnic.utexas.edu/asnic/index.html
* Center for South Asia, University of Wisconsin-Madison
http://www.southasia.wisc.edu/
* Council on Southeast Asia Studies, Yale University, Connecticut
http://www.yale.edu/seas/
Courtesy: SPAN Magazine |
Contact
editorspan@state.gov
|